The short version
Three words are often mixed up, but they describe different things:
- Conventional versus trunked is about how channels are organised.
- Analog versus digital is about how the voice is carried.
- Encrypted is separate from both. See the guide to encrypted radio.
A police department can be any combination: a conventional analog channel, a conventional digital channel, an analog trunked system, or a digital trunked system.
Conventional channels
A conventional channel is one frequency used by one group. You type the frequency into your scanner, add the tone if one is listed, set the mode, and listen.
- Many smaller agencies still use conventional channels, often with a repeater so the signal reaches the whole county.
- A listing shows a frequency, a tone (such as 156.7 PL), and a mode such as FM.
- Any scanner can receive an analog conventional channel. Digital conventional channels need a scanner that decodes that digital mode.
Trunked systems
A trunked system shares a pool of frequencies among many agencies. Instead of one frequency per group, each group gets a talkgroup number. A control channel tells radios and scanners where each call is happening.
- Larger agencies and statewide networks use trunking. One system can carry police, fire, EMS and public works.
- To follow one, you program the site's control channels and then pick talkgroups. See what the numbers mean.
- You need a trunking scanner, and it must support the system type shown.
Analog and digital voice
Analog voice is the sound itself, sent as FM. Digital voice is the sound turned into data and sent by a vocoder. The common digital modes in police radio are:
| Mode | What it is | Where you meet it |
|---|---|---|
| P25 Phase I | The main US public safety digital standard, one call per frequency | Many state and county systems |
| P25 Phase II | P25 with two calls sharing one frequency (TDMA) | Newer statewide and metro systems |
| DMR | A digital standard that also uses two time slots per frequency | Smaller departments, business systems |
| NXDN | A narrowband digital standard | Some small agencies and utilities |
Older systems used analog trunking types such as Motorola Type II, EDACS and LTR. They still exist.
What each listing needs
| The listing shows | You need a scanner that can |
|---|---|
| Mode FM or FMN, with a frequency and tone | Receive analog FM (any scanner) |
| P25 or a digital mode on a single frequency | Decode that digital mode on a conventional channel |
| A site with control channels and a P25 system | Follow trunked P25, and Phase II if the system is Phase II |
| A DMR or NXDN system | Decode DMR or NXDN, which some scanners sell as an add-on |
| An analog trunked system (Type II, EDACS, LTR) | Follow that trunking type |
Two cautions:
- Phase II is not the same as Phase I. Some older digital scanners follow Phase I only. If a system is Phase II, check that your scanner explicitly supports it.
- Digital is not encrypted. A digital channel can usually be received and decoded by a capable scanner. An encrypted one can't.
How to tell from a listing
- A conventional table has a frequency, tone, mode and callsign. If the mode is FM, FMN or AM, it's analog.
- A trunked system table has a talkgroup number in decimal and hex, an alpha tag and a mode code.
- The mode code letters describe the voice. A D usually means digital and a T means TDMA (Phase II). A trailing E marks traffic that is encrypted or sometimes encrypted.
- A site card lists control channels. If a county page shows sites, a trunking scanner is needed to hear the talkgroups above it.
Choosing a scanner
Choose by what the systems in your area use, not by price or brand:
- Look at your county page and write down the system types.
- Check whether any are Phase II, DMR or NXDN.
- Buy a scanner that supports all of them. If your local systems are analog only, a simple scanner is enough.
- Check whether your scanner needs a firmware update or a feature key to unlock a digital mode.
A software-defined radio with free decoding software can also receive many of these modes. It is a different set-up from a handheld or desktop scanner.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need a trunking scanner?
Only if you want trunked systems. If the traffic you want is on conventional channels, a conventional scanner is enough.
Why can't my old scanner hear the sheriff any more?
Many agencies have moved from conventional analog channels to digital trunked systems. A scanner that only handles analog conventional channels can't follow them. See why a frequency stopped working.
Is digital harder to listen to?
It needs a scanner that decodes it, and a strong signal. The sound is often clearer than analog when the signal is good. When the signal is weak, digital can drop out where analog would crackle.
Are digital channels encrypted?
No. Digital and encrypted are different things. Plenty of digital channels are unencrypted.